The stories we tell ourselves keep us stuck when we keep living by them after they’ve stopped working.
We learn most of our stories when we’re young. Our families, schools, and jobs teach us how to behave, what to think, and what we’re supposed to accomplish, and we build our lives around what we learned. When our lives need to change, we keep living the same stories, even after they’ve become too small for us.
Key Takeaways
- A story is what you learned about how to behave, think, and do. It keeps you stuck when you keep living from it after it stops fitting. (What a stuck story is)
- If you know what to do and still aren’t doing it, you’re usually facing a dilemma, not a gap in information. (Knowing what to do)
- The stories you were paid and praised for are the hardest to give up. (Paid and praised)
- A limiting belief is one line from a bigger story, so changing the line rarely works. (Limiting belief vs. story)
- You can find your story by looking at what you avoid doing, then trying what your old story doesn’t allow. (Seeing your story)
What does it mean to say a story is keeping you stuck?
A story is keeping you stuck when you’re still following it after it no longer fits your life. When I say story, I mean what you learned about how you’re supposed to behave, what to think about the world, and what you’re supposed to accomplish in it.
You learned most of your story through approval and shame. Growing up, you were praised for some of what you did and shamed for other things.
The parts of you that got praised became how you show up. The parts that got shamed, you learned to hide.
Your story also decides what you notice. In my post on self-schemas, I wrote about Hazel Markus’s research showing that the stories we hold about ourselves make us resist information that doesn’t fit them. So you can grow and still see yourself the way you did years ago.
You end up acting the way your story says someone like you acts.
Why doesn’t knowing what to do change anything?
Knowing what to do doesn’t change anything when you’re facing a dilemma instead of a problem. A problem has a solution you can look up. A dilemma is a fork in the road, and taking one path means giving up part of how you see yourself.

When water started coming into our house, I had a problem. The cause was clear, the fix was clear, and I called a plumber. Nothing about me had to change.
Most of what we’re taught is built for problems like that. Find the solution, then do it. When you’re facing a dilemma, the habit of looking up the answer sends you looking for more information, and more information doesn’t help because information wasn’t what you were missing.
Barry Mason, who writes about working with uncertainty, said that certainty is tempting but “usually fails to deliver what is wanted.” More certainty about the steps won’t get you through a dilemma.
To tell whether you’re facing a problem or a dilemma, pick something you said you’d do and haven’t done. Ask yourself whether you don’t know how, or whether something else is in the way. I go further into the difference in the knowing-doing gap.
Why do the stories you were paid and praised for become the hardest to change?
The stories you were paid and praised for are the hardest to change because they work.

When a story earns you money and approval, you keep living it, even when things get hard and it no longer fits.
If you look at the older posts on this site, you’ll see a lot of marketing. I still enjoy marketing, and I like what it does for people. But it was never my whole story.
Marketing was easy to get paid for and easy to be praised for. A lot of people want it, and a lot of people will pay for it.
Over time I realized I needed to step into a larger purpose. I wanted to work with people in a way I love, and for me that meant coaching.
Our stories usually start to change through a call or a fall. A fall is when something breaks and you’re trying to keep your life from falling apart. A call is when something asks you to become more than you’ve been.
There wasn’t a fall for me. Mine was a call, and the question it asked was whether I was willing to step into something greater.
Saying yes meant giving up the money I was making as a marketer. It also meant working in a field where a lot of people don’t understand coaching or value it the way they value marketing, and coaching has its own set of problems.
It took me years of learning to step into coaching fully. Staying in marketing would have been easier, because that story kept paying me and kept getting me praised.
I see the same thing with people who follow how-to advice exactly. They post every day, make all the videos, and grow the business to seven figures, and then it feels empty. How-to information can make you successful by following a script that has nothing to do with what drives you, and eventually you start asking what you really want to do.
What does a story problem look like at work and in business?
A story problem at work or in business usually means you know what to do, you’ve tried it, and you keep ending up in the same place. In my story coaching work, it tends to show up in one of these ways.
- You’re working toward a goal that isn’t yours. Say someone told you that you need a website, so you’ve been trying to build one for six months. It still isn’t done, and when you look closer, you may not want a website at all.
- You keep researching instead of starting. Reading and comparing options feels like progress. It also means you never have to put something out and find out how people respond.
- There’s a way of showing up you can’t picture yourself using. You can name how you usually show up, maybe as the helpful one or the easygoing one. Being direct about what you want isn’t something you can see yourself doing.
- You keep coming back to the same topic. When a client comes to a coaching session with nothing planned to talk about, they almost always end up on something they brought up a month or a few months earlier. That repeated topic usually points to the story they’re stuck in.
If your business is where you feel stuck, I wrote about what happens when you’ve outgrown the story that built your business.
What’s the difference between a limiting belief and a story?
A limiting belief is one sentence you believe about yourself, and it comes from a bigger story about who you are. Someone once asked me the difference, and I told them you can’t have a limiting belief without a story behind it. So changing the belief by itself rarely works.
Take a belief like “I can’t do outreach.” Behind it is a story about who does outreach, what it says about them, and what happens to people who try. Telling yourself “I can do outreach” doesn’t change the story about outreach you’ve been living.
When I help someone find their story, I don’t start with what they believe. I start with what they avoid doing, because what we avoid shows us the parts of our story we won’t let ourselves live.
How do you see the story you’re already living?
You see the story you’re living by looking at what you avoid doing, not only at what you believe. If you’ve ever asked yourself “what’s my story?”, the steps below are one way to answer it.

One tool I use is Carol Pearson’s twelve archetypes. The twelve are the Innocent, Orphan, Warrior, Caregiver, Seeker, Lover, Destroyer (also called Revolutionary), Creator, Ruler, Magician, Sage, and Jester.
I think of archetypes as energies that come through in how we act, like the Warrior’s energy when you go after a goal or the Creator’s energy when you make something new. Most of us live two or three of them all the time and rarely use the rest. The ones we rarely use are usually where our story won’t let us go.
I live out the Seeker, Warrior, Revolutionary, and Sage a lot. When a meeting drifted off track, I could feel it in my forearms, and all I wanted was to get something done. I sabotaged those meetings because I was so focused on living one kind of story that I wasn’t present for what was happening in the room.
When I let more of the other archetypes come through, I had more flexibility in how I responded. Here’s how to look at the archetypes you live most and least.
- Pick the two you use most. They’re the ones you use without thinking, at work and at home.
- Pick the two you use least. The ones you use least usually cause the most trouble when you’re stuck. Notice what happens when you picture using them, including where you feel it in your body.
- Write down what you heard growing up about the two you use least. What did you hear about being strong, going after goals, or being the one in charge?
- Choose one goal for this week and watch what happens. If you don’t do it, ask whether you don’t know how or whether something else is in the way. Also ask whether the goal is yours or one you took on to keep someone else happy.
- Check in at the end of each day. Ask what you were aiming for, how it went, and where you stopped yourself.
You can work through these steps on your own if you write down what you notice. If you can’t see the pattern, it helps to have someone who asks good questions and notices when your voice changes.
What do you do once you can see the story?
Once you can see your story, start trying the things your story hasn’t let you do, and then look at what happened. If you said you’d do something and didn’t, ask what got in the way. You’ll usually need to try more than once.
Our stories usually start to change through a call or a fall, something that pulls us toward more or something that breaks. Either way, the ways you’ve always handled problems stop working.
You keep using them anyway, because they’re what you know, and they keep failing. Some people call this stretch the dark night of the soul or the valley of despair.
It’s frustrating, and the frustration is what finally shows you that you can’t keep living the way you have been. At some point you have to surrender the old ways of handling problems and be open to a new way of living. Letting go of them is scary, and it’s a big reason people stay stuck.
As you start living a new way, the things that used to keep you trapped or limited aren’t as strong. You’re making room for the archetypes, feelings, and beliefs you used to push down, and that lets you live more fully.
To try something new, you need to feel safe enough to act without knowing how it will turn out. Barry Mason calls this safe uncertainty. You don’t know what will happen, but you feel safe enough to explore.
Having another person helps you get there. A coach, a friend, or a partner who listens gives you room to say an idea out loud before you’ve decided it won’t work.
In my book, I break changing your story into three parts. You see the story, you shift the story, and you live from the new one. This post covers the first part, seeing your story.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can the stories we tell ourselves really keep us stuck?
Yes. In my coaching, the stories people live by are often what keeps them stuck. Stories are a foundational way we understand ourselves, others, and the world. How we view things determines how we react, respond, and navigate the world.
Also, a review of narrative identity studies found that themes in people’s life stories predict well-being beyond what personality traits explain.
Is changing your story the same as positive thinking?
No. Changing your story goes further than changing your thinking. Thinking is how we work with the ideas, images, symbols, and information we have, and positive thinking puts a positive vibe on whatever we’re thinking about.
Your stories are what run your life. They shape what feels meaningful to you, and that meaning shapes the feelings and emotions you have.
Changing your thinking can change how you see an idea without changing your life. Changing your story changes what matters to you, and it lets you see your life as bigger and less constricted.
Can you find your story without a coach?
Yes, you can start finding your story on your own if you write about it and notice when you stop yourself. A short check-in at the end of each day is enough to start. If you can’t see the pattern after a while, talk it through with someone, even a friend who listens without giving advice.
What’s my story?
Your story is what you learned about how to behave, what to think, and what to accomplish, based on what got you approval and what got you shamed. You find it by noticing which ways of acting you use most, which you avoid, and what you were told about them.
Is being stuck in a story a mental health problem?
No, being stuck in a story isn’t a mental health condition, but the two can overlap. If low mood, anxiety, or something heavier is part of what you’re dealing with, talk to a licensed therapist. Coaching isn’t a substitute for that.
I’m building a course on seeing and changing your story. If you’d like to hear when it opens, join the waitlist.
