In most cases, people don’t know what they want because they’ve lost touch with the part of them that really knows what they want.
Many of us spend years looking to courses, mentors, and other people’s ideas of success for our answers. Over time, we stop checking with ourselves first. Figuring out what you want starts with reconnecting with yourself and paying attention to what you already know.
Key Takeaways
- In most cases, not knowing what you want comes from being disconnected from yourself. (Why you don’t know what you want)
- Values lists and vision boards often don’t help, because they ask you to come up with answers on the spot and most of their prompts point you toward other people. (Why the exercises haven’t worked)
- The longer you rely on other people to tell you what to want, the harder it gets to hear what you think and feel. (Why it gets harder)
- You can reconnect by starting with what you already know, like what drains you and what you keep coming back to, and by making one small decision a week that you follow through on. (How to reconnect)
Why don’t I know what I want?
There are a lot of reasons someone might not know what they want. My belief is that, in most cases, people don’t know what they want because they’ve become disconnected from the part of them that knows.
Gabor Maté, a physician who has written for years about this kind of disconnection, described in an interview how it starts. When we’re children, we learn that some of our feelings cost us acceptance from the people we depend on. So we push those feelings down to stay close to them.
Maté said that by mid-life, many people realize “they’ve been living lives that were not their own lives at all.” He says this happens because they got disconnected from themselves.
I believe the same thing happens with what we want. When you spend years pushing down what you feel to keep other people happy, you also lose touch with what you want. I wrote more about how what we learn growing up shapes the rest of our lives in how the stories we tell ourselves keep us stuck.
Being disconnected also changes where you need to look for an answer. If the problem is disconnection, reading more advice from other people won’t help much. What helps is spending time reconnecting with yourself.
Why haven’t the values lists and vision boards worked?
Values lists, vision boards, wheel-of-life charts, and personal SWOT exercises often don’t help people figure out what they want. These exercises ask you to come up with answers on the spot, and that’s hard to do when you’re disconnected from yourself.
Most articles on figuring out what you want suggest some version of these exercises. They ask you to rank your values, picture your ideal future, or think about what would impress the people you admire.
I see two problems with these exercises.
- The first is that they expect the answers to show up as soon as you ask. If you’ve lost touch with what you want, you can end up with words like “freedom” and “impact” written in a notebook that don’t mean much to you.
- The second problem is that most of the prompts point you toward other people. They ask about role models, milestones, and what success is supposed to look like. If you’ve spent years getting your answers from other people, these exercises have you do the same thing again.
Psychology Today suggests starting with what you don’t want and turning it around into what you do want. I think this works because what you don’t want is something you can easily notice. Noticing what you don’t want is a first step toward reconnecting with yourself.
If you’ve found that more information doesn’t fix this, I wrote about why in the knowing-doing gap. More information usually isn’t what’s missing.
What does being disconnected from yourself look like?
For a business owner, being disconnected from yourself can look like making confident decisions for clients all day and drawing a blank when the decision is about you. You can answer “what should this business do next?” right away, but “what do I want?” is hard to answer.
Here are a few other ways being disconnected shows up.
- You make decisions based on what clients need, what makes sense for the market, or what success is supposed to look like, and what you want doesn’t come into it.
- You can argue for any side of a decision, so you keep asking another mentor, another peer, or an AI tool, and you still don’t feel closer to an answer.
- Things look fine on paper, but you keep thinking “I don’t know what I want anymore.”
I’ve been through this myself. Years into running my marketing business, everything was fine. I had good clients, leads were coming in, I had no debt, and I was hitting the goals I set.
But I noticed I could set a goal, achieve it, and still not feel like it was what I needed.
A friend told me I didn’t need to stop achieving. What I needed was more mindfulness. My friend meant spending time connecting with myself so my real thoughts, dreams, and feelings had room to come through.
Mindfulness helped me get out of my default habits. I became more aware of what I was doing and why I was doing it.
Over time, that practice led me to pursue coaching and personal development in a way I hadn’t been able to before. I didn’t find new information. What changed was that I got back in touch with what I was thinking and feeling.

Why does it get harder over time, not easier?
I believe figuring out what you want gets harder the longer you rely on other people to answer the question for you. Each time you ask a course, a mentor, or an AI tool what you should want, you get more used to looking outside yourself. Over time, it gets harder to hear what you think and feel.
I think this is why people who have taken the most courses and gotten the most advice often have the hardest time answering the question. They’ve had the most practice looking for answers outside themselves.
A client of mine had spent $150,000 on business programs over the years. None of the programs gave her what they promised, and she called working with me her last Hail Mary.
She explained why the programs hadn’t worked for her. They assumed where she was in her journey, and when they got that wrong, the information didn’t help her.
What she was missing wasn’t skills. She had lost touch with what she cared about. She had spent years buying other people’s answers, and no program could tell her what she wanted.
How do you reconnect with what you actually want?
You reconnect with what you want by starting with what you already know. Even when you don’t know what you want, you usually know what drains you, what you resent, and what you keep coming back to. You can start there and make one small decision at a time.
Here’s how I’d start.
- Write down what you know you don’t want. Be specific. Instead of “less stress,” write something like “I don’t want to spend another Monday on this client’s revisions.” What you don’t want is often the easiest thing to notice, so it’s a good place to start.
- Notice what keeps pulling at you. Pay attention to the work you do when nobody asks you to, and to the people whose lives you find yourself wanting. What you long for can tell you what’s missing from your life right now.
- Make one decision a week based on what you want, and follow through on it. The decision can be small. You might turn down one request or block off one morning for something you keep thinking about. The size of the decision doesn’t matter as much as practicing listening to yourself and acting on what you hear.
- Expect this to take time. Carl Jung called this process individuation. He meant becoming who you really are, instead of who you learned to be for other people, and he saw it as the main work of the second half of life. I’ve seen the same thing in my coaching work, and I’ve written about how we understand ourselves through stories. You find out what you want by trying things and paying attention to how they feel, more than by reading about it.
None of this means you have to blow up your business or your life. It takes about an hour a week of honest attention, and a willingness to take what you notice seriously.
What you want usually comes back slowly. Each small decision you follow through on makes it easier to trust yourself.

Frequently Asked Questions
Is it normal to not know what you want at 40?
Yes, it’s common not to know what you want at 40, and mid-life is often when the question comes up. Maté has said that people in mid-life are often the ones who realize they’ve been living lives that weren’t their own. Jung saw the second half of life as the time when people work on becoming who they really are. If you’re asking this question now, you’re not behind.
What if everything is fine on paper and I still feel this way?
Feeling lost when everything looks fine on paper is common. It often means you reached goals that came mostly from other people, like what success is supposed to look like. The flat feeling usually comes from the part of you that never got asked what it wanted. It’s worth paying attention to, because it tends to get stronger over time.
How long does it take to figure out what you want?
There’s no set timeline for figuring out what you want, because it’s something you practice more than something you research. Many people find their first honest answer sooner than they expect once they start with what they already know. Most people can name what they don’t want today, and they can build from there one decision at a time.
