Solo business owner pausing at his home-office desk before publishing a blog post, illustrating why authentic marketing feels hard for solopreneurs.

Awareness

Authentic Marketing Sounds Simple. So Why Can’t You Do It?

Authentic marketing is hard because it asks you to let people see who you are.

Most of us learned when we were young which parts of ourselves got praised and which parts got shamed. In our marketing, we show the parts we’ve been praised for, like our skills and the work we’re good at, and we hold the rest of ourselves back. Holding back part of yourself is what makes authentic marketing feel so hard.

Key Takeaways

  • Authentic marketing means being yourself in your marketing. When it feels hard, you’re usually holding back part of who you are. (Why “just be authentic” is hard to follow)
  • Most of us show the parts of ourselves we’ve been praised for and hide the rest. Letting people see more of you means they can judge you, reject you, or ignore you. (What authentic marketing asks of you)
  • Disappearing from your marketing for weeks and then posting out of guilt is a way of protecting yourself. Feeling like a fraud when you promote yourself is common. (Why you keep disappearing)
  • How to do marketing is free on YouTube, Google, and AI tools. When your marketing keeps stalling, the harder question is what you want to show the world. (Whether it’s really a marketing problem)
  • Marketing that doesn’t feel fake is marketing you’d be comfortable putting your name on. (What that looks like)

Why is “just be authentic” so hard to follow?

“Just be authentic” is hard to follow because being authentic means being yourself in your marketing, and most of us have spent years showing people only part of ourselves.

You’ve probably seen the advice on LinkedIn and Instagram. People tell you to show your face, use your own voice, tell your stories, and stop worrying about looking perfect.

The advice is good. Following the advice is the hard part, because following it means letting people see more of you than you’re used to showing.

In my experience, when marketing feels hard, the person usually isn’t in touch with how they want to show up. If you haven’t decided what you want people to see, every post can feel like a risk.

What does authentic marketing ask you to do?

Authentic marketing asks you to let people see you. Along with the work you do, people get to see your opinions, your story, and how you think.

Most of us learned when we were young which parts of ourselves got praised and which parts got shamed. The parts of us that got praised became how we show up. The parts that got shamed, we learned to hide. I wrote more about how we learn these stories in how the stories we tell ourselves keep us stuck.

Marketing brings the same pattern out. We put forward the parts of ourselves we’ve been praised for or know we’re good at, like our credentials, our results, and our skills. Our opinions, our personal stories, and the way we see things stay out of our marketing.

Showing the parts you’ve kept hidden feels risky. Once people can see you, they can judge you, reject you, or ignore you.

When someone tells me they need better marketing, what they often want is a safer way to be seen.

Polished, templated content gives you a safer way to be seen. You can market your business without people seeing much of who you are.

Why do you keep disappearing from your marketing?

Disappearing from your marketing for weeks and then posting out of guilt is a way of protecting yourself. One part of you wants to be visible, and another part of you wants to stay safe from being judged.

Business owner sitting at her kitchen-table workspace with her phone face-down, in the disappear-and-feel-guilty stretch of an inconsistent marketing cycle.

Feeling uncomfortable about promoting yourself is common. A review of 62 studies covering more than 14,000 people looked at impostor feelings, which is the sense that you’re a fraud who’s about to be found out. Depending on how each study measured them, as many as 82% of people reported impostor feelings. Men and women reported them at every stage of their careers.

Other research on self-promotion found that women in particular are often judged more harshly when they promote themselves. Because the judgment is real, holding back from promoting yourself is a reasonable way to avoid it.

So if you post, disappear, feel guilty, and then post again, you’re trying to market yourself while part of you is working to keep you from being judged.

Sticking more closely to a content calendar doesn’t change what that part of you is afraid of.

Is your marketing problem really a marketing problem?

When a marketing problem keeps coming back, the cause is usually that you haven’t figured out what you want to show the world.

I’ve spent years in marketing, managing millions of dollars in ad spend and building funnels. I’ve also worked with a lot of people on their marketing.

Information on how to market a business is everywhere. You can find it on YouTube, on Google, and in any AI chat tool, and most of it is free.

If you’re having trouble doing your marketing, you can look up how to do it in a few minutes. The harder part is deciding what you want to present to the world, and deciding what to present is where most of the people I’ve worked with get stuck.

Real marketing problems are easier to point to. You might be talking to the wrong audience, your offer might be weak, you might not be getting enough traffic, or one step in your funnel might be broken. You can test each of these problems, fix it, and watch your numbers change.

When the same trouble shows up after a new strategy, a new course, or a rebrand, look at what you’re comfortable letting people see. I wrote about why knowing what to do often isn’t enough in the knowing-doing gap.

What does marketing that doesn’t feel fake look like?

Marketing that doesn’t feel fake is marketing you’d be comfortable putting your name on. Here are three things I’d look for.

  • You believe what you’re saying about your offer. If writing the promise for your offer makes you uncomfortable, take a look at the offer itself. Sometimes the discomfort means you’ve outgrown what you’re selling. I wrote about outgrowing the story you built your business on in the stories we tell ourselves.
  • You post at a pace you can keep up. One post a week that you can keep doing is better than posting every day for two weeks and then disappearing for a month.
  • You say what you think, in your own words. Share what you’ve seen in your work and what you believe about it, even when you’re not sure everyone will agree.
Solopreneur writing a blog post in her own words at a coffee shop, at ease with being visible, showing what authentic marketing that doesn't feel fake looks like.

There’s also a practical reason to market this way. About 80% of marketers now use AI to create content, and a lot of what gets posted looks and sounds the same. Adam Mosseri, who runs Instagram, has said that polished, professional-looking content used to signal quality and now signals the opposite.

Polished content used to let you market your business without being seen. Polished content doesn’t work as well anymore, because people are looking for a real person behind what they read.

The question worth spending time on is what you want people to see when they find you.

Frequently Asked Questions

How do I market my business without feeling salesy?

Marketing feels less salesy when what you say matches what you believe. Write about your offer the way you’d talk about it with someone in person. If you’d feel uncomfortable saying a claim out loud, leave the claim out.

Is it normal to hate promoting your own business?

Yes, it’s normal to hate promoting your own business. Research on impostor feelings found them in as many as 82% of people in some studies. If promoting your business feels uncomfortable, a lot of other people feel the same way.

Do I have to show my face online to grow my business?

No, you don’t have to show your face online to grow your business. Plenty of businesses grow through writing, email, and referrals. What people do need to see is how you think, and you can share your point of view in whatever format you’re comfortable with.


If this post describes how marketing feels for you, another marketing course probably won’t help much. What helps is taking time to figure out what you want people to see. My free guide, Step Back to Move Forward, gives you a structured way to do that.

Joseph Bojang.

Helping you see the story you're living from, and grow into a larger one.

Elsewhere