A solopreneur sitting at a familiar home-office desk staring at the ceiling, visibly stuck in a routine that no longer feels comfortable

Coaching

Your Comfort Zone Isn’t Comfortable. It’s Just Familiar.

Your comfort zone is the place where things feel familiar. Familiar isn’t always the same as comfortable.

A lot of us stay in our comfort zone because we know what to expect there, even when we don’t enjoy it. When leaving our comfort zone feels hard, the reason is usually has to do with how we see ourselves. The routines, roles, and work we’ve had for years become part of who we think we are. Leaving our comfort zone means changing how we see ourselves, and changing how we see ourselves is the hard part.

Key Takeaways

  • Your comfort zone is the place that feels familiar. Many people who say they’re stuck in their comfort zone feel stressed, tired, or resentful there. (What a comfort zone is)
  • Our brains like what they recognize. A situation we know well takes less mental effort to handle, even when the situation drains us. (Why your comfort zone can feel uncomfortable)
  • We often stay in a situation that isn’t working because leaving would mean becoming someone we don’t recognize yet. (Why we stay)
  • Knowing what to do and doing it are two different things. The gap between them is often about who you’d have to become. (How this connects to the knowing-doing gap)
  • Getting out of your comfort zone starts with naming what you’re protecting, calling your comfort zone what it is, and letting yourself be new at something. (What helps)

What is a comfort zone?

A comfort zone is a familiar psychological state. The common definition says that in a comfort zone, people feel at ease, feel in control of what’s around them, and have low levels of anxiety and stress.

Your comfort zone can also be physical. It can be the routines, the places, and the kind of work you’ve done for years.

The definition describes how a comfort zone is supposed to feel. If you feel stuck in your comfort zone, you might not recognize that description at all. You might feel stressed by your calendar. You might resent some of your clients, or the version of yourself you have to be every day to keep your business running.

Most of us still call this place our comfort zone, because “comfort zone” is the phrase we’ve all heard. The word “comfort” makes it sound like we stay because staying feels good. So when we can’t make ourselves leave, we decide we must be lazy or scared.

If you feel stressed or resentful in your comfort zone, you aren’t staying because it feels good. Something else is keeping you there.

Why does your comfort zone feel so uncomfortable?

Your comfort zone can feel uncomfortable because your brain likes what it recognizes, whether or not the situation is good for you. A familiar situation takes less mental effort to handle than a new one.

Psychologist Robert Zajonc found that when people saw the same unfamiliar thing again and again, like a shape or a character from a language they couldn’t read, they started to like it more. His finding is called the mere exposure effect. This Psychology Today article explains one reason we like familiar things. Familiar things are easier for our brains to process, because we already know what to expect.

The same research has a limit. Past a certain point, more familiarity makes us like something less, and we start to feel bored. So a situation can be familiar enough that you’ve stopped enjoying it, and it can still feel easier than something new.

Two ideas from behavioral economics help explain why we stay anyway. The first is loss aversion. Loss aversion means losing something feels worse than gaining something feels good. The pain of a loss is thought to be about twice as strong as the pleasure of a gain. When you think about leaving a situation, you notice what you’d lose more than what you’d gain.

The second idea is status quo bias, which is a preference for keeping things the way they are. Status quo bias pulls us toward our current situation, even when another option might be better.

Put together, these ideas explain why a situation that drains you can still feel safer than a change. Your comfort zone is often stress you already know how to handle.

A business owner sitting at his kitchen table at dawn, holding his phone, in a morning routine he knows well

Why do you stay in a situation you know isn’t working?

We stay in situations that aren’t working because leaving would change who we are, and changing who we are feels risky. Over time, the way we work and live becomes part of how we see ourselves.

Robert Kegan and Lisa Lahey, who teach at the Harvard Graduate School of Education, call this pattern immunity to change. Their work looks at why people who want to change, and have plenty of motivation, still don’t change.

One reason is what Kegan and Lahey call competing commitments. A competing commitment is something else you’re committed to, often without realizing it, that the change would threaten. For example, you might want to raise your prices while you’re also committed to being seen as the easygoing, affordable one.

Research on identity-based motivation points in the same direction. Psychologist Daphna Oyserman’s work finds that people prefer to act in ways that fit who they believe they are. When an action doesn’t fit who you believe you are, the action feels harder to take.

A client of mine is a good example. He told me, “All I do is think about money and work on money and study money.” He was doing better emotionally than he ever had. At the same time, he was at the worst financial point of his life.

He had read the books and learned the frameworks. He didn’t need more information about money. He needed to let himself become someone who goes after money.

Pushing harder rarely works when the real problem is who you’d have to become. You can’t force your way past a part of your identity you haven’t looked at yet.

What does your comfort zone have to do with the knowing-doing gap?

The knowing-doing gap is the space between knowing what you should do and actually doing it. Your comfort zone is often where the knowing-doing gap shows up, because doing what you know you should do would mean leaving what’s familiar.

I wrote about the knowing-doing gap in more detail in The Knowing-Doing Gap. Most of the business owners I work with already know what to do. They’ve taken the courses, learned the strategies, and written the plans. Their plans didn’t stick because following them meant becoming a version of themselves they hadn’t met yet.

One client had a sticky note on her wall that said, “Stop being distracted by things that have nothing to do with your goals.” She wrote the note herself, and the note had been on her wall for five years.

A year into building her business, she was still losing hours every day to social media, house projects, and anything besides her work. She understood her pattern. Understanding her pattern didn’t change her behavior.

Knowing the problem isn’t the same as solving it.

When someone has known about a pattern for years and still hasn’t changed it, more information won’t help. The pattern is tied to a story about who they are. I wrote about how we learn those stories in how the stories we tell ourselves keep us stuck.

How do you get out of your comfort zone if pushing harder doesn’t work?

To get out of your comfort zone, start by seeing the pattern that keeps you there. Pushing harder usually doesn’t work, because pushing doesn’t change what you’re protecting. Three things help.

Name what you’re protecting. Ask yourself which part of how you see yourself you’d have to let go of if you did the thing you know you should do. Your answer might be the version of you that people already know, or a role you’ve played for years. Whatever you find is your competing commitment. Once you can name your competing commitment, it has less control over what you do.

Call your comfort zone what it is. When you say you need to leave your comfort zone, it sounds like you’ve been choosing ease and now need to choose something hard. If your comfort zone has been stressful, that description doesn’t fit. You’ve been choosing the familiar because a change would mean becoming someone new. Becoming someone new is a different problem from being lazy, and it needs a different answer than “just do it.”

Let yourself be new at the next thing. When you start something new, there’s a stretch of time when you don’t know who you are yet. You’ve stopped being the old version of yourself, and the new version doesn’t feel natural yet. The in-between stretch is uncomfortable, and many of us go back to what’s familiar as soon as we feel it. Feeling awkward during the in-between stretch is normal. Feeling awkward usually means you’ve started.

Getting out of your comfort zone takes seeing what you’ve been protecting, then staying with something new long enough for the new thing to become familiar.

A woman standing in the doorway of an unfamiliar room, about to step into something new

Frequently Asked Questions

Is it normal to feel uncomfortable in your comfort zone?

Yes, it’s normal to feel uncomfortable in your comfort zone. A comfort zone is a place that feels familiar, and a familiar situation can still be stressful. We tend to prefer situations we know, partly because they take less mental effort, so we can stay in a situation that drains us.

What’s the difference between a comfort zone and being stuck?

A comfort zone is a situation that feels familiar and easy to handle. Being stuck is staying in a familiar situation after it has stopped working for you. Most people who say they’re stuck in their comfort zone mean the second one. Staying feels safer than changing, because losing what you have tends to feel worse than gaining something new feels good.

Why does leaving your comfort zone feel like losing yourself?

Leaving your comfort zone can feel like losing yourself because your current situation has become part of how you see yourself. When you change the situation, you also have to change how you see yourself. People prefer to act in ways that fit who they believe they are, so an action that doesn’t fit yet feels risky.

 

Joseph Bojang.

Helping you see the story you're living from, and grow into a larger one.

Elsewhere